They receive well over 10,000 new members each month and have about five times as many active members as most other Catholic dating sites.
If your Catholic faith is important to you and you wish to meet someone with similar values and be part of a real community of single Catholics, give Catholic a try. Catholic Match is not wholesome the men just want to sleep with the women.
In fact there is no appeal process and if you do get banned one day your account is just "closed" without any comment (know of 3 men this happened to).
It appears that there is some insider relationship with moderators who will create false profiles (impossibly attractive "too good to be true" women) who's first post is to you to get you in the forums is to talk to them in private and reveal personal information so they can figure out more about you.
Also - if you don't read your email on the first forward notice subsequent notifications are never forwarded so you can miss contacts if you are ignoring users who you do not want to reply to unless you log on frequently to check mail and activity. The absolutely need an appeal process for complaints and active moderation of ALL forums since its has degraded so bad now that most just post childish and safe "non adult" questions like "what is your favorite song" or "what do you do with a man who talks to much on a date" (male bashing is ok).
I read the prior comments about the site being overrun by too orthodox/ conservative but i can tell you that the ultra liberal pseudo-Catholics who can not even marry in the Church due to divorce with no anullment now haunt the place.
So I am laughing since these gang up on those who appear as "too conservative" and no one is stopping it.
The CM staff makes everything possible to limit your communication and actually to keep you on the site as long as possible.
There is a very low limit of 10-15 messages you can send to different people, whom you have not spoken to at a given time and they send warning messages when somebody wants to share offline contacts and move the relationship on the next level, because they want to keep it all on CM and keep you paying as much as you can.
Disclaimer: While we make every effort to ensure the accuracy and reliability of our information at Dating Sites we shall not be held responsible for any discrepancy. Some of the men have been on the site for ten plus years and they still don't want someone to marry just to hook up with or chat with so they can feel better about themselves as they all seem to be odd.